Romantic Comedy Up Next at Peninsula Players Theatre

Peninsula Players Theatre, America’s oldest professional resident summer theater and Door County’s theatrical icon, is thrilled to announce the cast and creative team for “Romance in D” by James Sherman, performing August 24 through September 19.  This romantic comedy follows the lovable but awkward Isabel Fox (Cassandra Bissell) and Charles Norton (Neil Brookshire), two neighbors who develop a friendship while resisting their meddling parents.  Meanwhile, Helen and George (Judy Blue and Greg Vinkler), who, unbeknownst to their kids, happen to start their own romance.  “Romance in D” is generously sponsored by Tim and Jackie Danis.  

Charles, a musicologist, has insulated himself from romantic entanglements. He keeps himself occupied with work, casual friendships and food visits from his mother, Helen, the self-proclaimed soup fairy.  Isabel, a brokenhearted poet, moves into the apartment next door and has only her visiting father, George, for company.  After Charles unexpectedly rescues Isabel from a half-hearted suicide attempt, his loving yet sometimes overbearing mother tries to push the two of them together.  The parents themselves finally meet and all four surprisingly discover that true love can blossom when you least expect it.  

Sherman’s other works include the popular comedies “Beau Jest” and “Jest a Second.” Sherman began his professional career as a writer and performer with The Second City in Chicago.  Since 1986, he has been a playwright-in-residence at the Tony Award-winning Victory Gardens Theater in Chicago. He has been the recipient of fellowships from the MacDowell Colony, the Ragdale Foundation and the Virginia Center for the Arts.  He is a member of the The Dramatists Guild of America.   His other plays include “Magic Time,” “The God of Isaac” and “Mr. 80%.”

The veteran cast of “Romance in D” includes alumni Cassandra Bissell, Judy Blue, Neil Brookshire and Greg Vinkler.  All are under the direction of another alum, Tom Mula, who marks his 26th season with the company and his 35th production.  Mula directed the world premieres of “The Tin Woman,” “Making God Laugh” and “Now and Then,” as well as performed in numerous shows. 

Bissell and Brookshire last appeared at Peninsula Players Theatre in productions of “Silent Sky,” “A Murder is Announced,” “A Trick of the Light” and “Miss Holmes.” They also co-wrote the radio play “It Sounds Like a Christmas Carol” that the theater presented in December of 2020 as part of its winter programming “The Play’s the Thing.” Bissell has performed in 17 productions at the theater-in-a-garden and this is Brookshire’s fourth season after making his debut in the 2016 production of “The 39 Steps.” Both have extensive stage credits in and out of Wisconsin, with several professional Shakespeare festivals and numerous Chicago stages.  Brookshire spent 10 seasons with the Idaho Shakespeare Festival before relocating to the Midwest.  Both now call Door County home.

Blue and Vinkler last appeared together in the 2017 world première of “The Actuary” as a married couple.  In “Romance in D,” they will portray widowers who take a shine to each other.  Blue, a veteran of several national tours, has extensive stage credits from coast to coast. She has workshopped new plays as both a director and actor with Chicago Dramatists for over 25 years. Her audiobook narration includes the Sleuth Sisters mystery series and the award-winning Myrtle Clover series.  

Since 1988, Vinkler has directed 33 productions, including “Chicago,” “Lombardi” and “The Full Monty,” and has performed in 51 shows.  He appeared on Broadway in the Tony Award-winning revival of “West Side Story” and also at the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford-upon-Avon, the Barbican Theatre in London, Vienna’s English Theatre and Singapore Rep.

The creative team of “Romance in D” includes award-winning designers Jack Magaw, scenic design; Kärin Simonson Kopischke, costume design; Stephen Roy White, lighting design; and Joe Court, sound design. Magaw, Simonson Kopischke, Court and White were part of the 2019 creative team of “Silent Sky.” 

Peninsula Players Theatre is a professional theater that produces live stage works in collaboration with its union partners at Actors’ Equity Association (AEA), United Scenic Artists (USA) and the Society of Directors and Choreographers (SDC).  These partners have approved the many safety protocols the theater put in place to re-open in late July.

As a reminder to theatergoers, the side panels, doors and vents of the audience pavilion will remain open throughout the 90-minute comedy. Patrons should dress for the weather and be prepared for shifting temperatures or breezes off the bay. All parties will be socially distanced and seated with no one directly in front, behind or two seats to the left or right of them. For the most current safety protocols at the theater, visit before attending a performance. 

“Romance in D” performs Tuesdays through Saturdays at 7:00 p.m. and Sundays at 2:00 p.m.  The theater and its offices will be closed on Mondays. To book tickets or for more information, visit